Circle Sentencing
Repairing Harm. Restoring Balance. Rebuilding Community.

What if, instead of asking only what punishment fits a particular offense, we asked a different set of questions?
Who has been harmed? What needs to happen to repair that harm? How can the person responsible be held accountable? And what will help restore a sense of safety and balance to the community?
These are the questions at the heart of Circle Sentencing, a restorative justice process that brings people together to address harm and develop a meaningful plan for moving forward.
Bringing Everyone to the Circle
Circle Sentencing is similar in many ways to the family team meeting model. Both recognize that the people most directly affected by a situation have knowledge, relationships, and resources that professionals alone may not possess.
A sentencing circle may include the person who caused the harm, the person who was harmed (if they choose to participate), their relatives, and other people who have a meaningful connection to the situation.
Judges, law enforcement officers, social workers, counselors, and other professionals may participate when appropriate.
But some of the most important participants are community peacemakers—respected members of the community who bring experience, wisdom, compassion, and a commitment to the well-being of everyone involved.
They are not there to exact revenge. They are there because they care about their community and recognize their responsibility for helping to keep it safe.
Being recognized as a community peacemaker is both an honor and a responsibility.
A Different Understanding of Justice
During my graduate research in 2001, I became particularly interested in traditional Indigenous approaches to community responsibility, including teachings associated with Mohawk society.
What struck me was the emphasis on belonging, relationships, and maintaining harmony within the community.
In a community organized around kinship and shared responsibility, everyone has a place. Everyone has something to contribute. Everyone matters.
And when someone causes harm, the questions go beyond what that individual did.
What happened in this person’s life? Where did relationships break down? What responsibilities were neglected? What does the person who was harmed need? And what can the community do to help prevent further harm?
The point is not to excuse harmful behavior or transfer responsibility away from the person who caused it.
The point is to recognize that punishment alone does not necessarily repair what has been damaged.
Sometimes a meaningful plan might involve helping an elder, listening to family stories, returning to school, addressing substance use, making restitution, or taking on responsibilities that reconnect a person with the community.
The response must fit the circumstances, protect those affected, and address the actual harm.
This is justice concerned not only with what has happened, but with what happens next.
And it recognizes that the decisions we make today affect the kind of community our children and grandchildren will inherit.
Building a Sentencing Circle in Winnebago, Nebraska
When I worked as a restorative justice specialist for the Winnebago Tribe of Nebraska, I developed a Circle Sentencing program within the Tribal Court.
One of our first circles involved a young man who had suddenly accumulated five criminal charges.
Rather than concentrating solely on punishment, we looked at what was happening in his life and what he needed to do differently.
The plan we developed was surprisingly straightforward:
Go to school. Stay awake in class. Do your homework. Earn decent grades. Stay sober. And find something physical and constructive to do.
He was interested in boxing because his grandfather had been a boxer.
Wonderful. Let’s make boxing part of the plan.
We continued meeting every few weeks, checking on his progress, listening, encouraging, and holding him accountable.
I’d love to tell you that he immediately turned his life around, graduated from Harvard, and lived happily ever after.
That’s not what happened.
Real change is seldom that simple.
But the circle had a profound impact on his life, and I remained connected with him and his family long after my work with the Tribe ended.
What I Learned
I’d also love to tell you that the Circle Sentencing program transformed the entire community overnight.
It didn’t.
And that experience taught me something important.
A circle isn’t magic. It’s a process that requires genuine participation, commitment, and a willingness to take responsibility.
People have to be willing to listen, examine their own assumptions, acknowledge harm, and participate in making things right.
That includes individuals, families, professionals, and the community itself.
A circle cannot manufacture that commitment. It can, however, create an opportunity for it to emerge.
And when people are willing to do that work, something becomes possible that a sentence imposed from outside may never accomplish.
People begin to recognize their own ability to make decisions, solve problems, repair relationships where possible, and take responsibility for their future.
For me, that is the promise of restorative justice.
The answers don’t always have to come from someone outside the circle. Sometimes the wisdom, the resources, and the possibilities are already sitting right there among the people involved.