The first time I worked with this family was in early October, 2009; the second time was several months ago. The first time was a disaster, I’m guessing most onlookers would have said.
Ariel, a mother of two little girls, came into the conference room with two sisters, her mother, another sister on the phone, her social worker, and a native liaison worker. It was still an “informal” case because the family wanted to report her behavior, but didn’t want her to get in trouble. So there were no attorneys working with the case, no care coordinators, no other workers; just the family and the social worker.
We started the family team meeting. We introduced ourselves to one another; we got through Ariel’s list of ground rules that she had chosen for the meeting that day; and we agreed that the purpose of the meeting would be for Ariel to “continue doing what she was doing already,” which was the purpose Ariel had come up with during our one-on-one meeting in the weeks before the family team meeting. I asked Ariel to share with the group “her story,” or what it was that got her involved with the social services agency.
She started to tell her story, and her mom jumped in to correct her; that’s when the yelling and screaming began.
At the end of about an hour of back-and-forth screaming from mother to daughter and daughter to mother, with sisters interrupting from time to time to try to calm one of the screamers or reason with them, with mother and daughter resolutely screaming at each other about various things such as Ariel being adopted, being native, and her family being non-native, about whether her family ever loved her or not, or accepted her native ancestry or not, or whether Ariel ever accepted her non-native adoptive family for being non-native, and after hurling all the insults they could think of at one another and using the F-word and every other mean, torturous, ugly verbal attack in their arsenal – anyone could tell these people were well-practiced at the art of being brutally mean to each other – Ariel screamed to her mom, “You’ve always told me that you were going to get my kids taken away from me. Now. Here you go. Are you happy? They’re going to get taken away.”
By this time everyone in the room was so shaken up, and Ariel was in tears and all worked up, her mom and her sisters were both in tears and all worked up, and the social worker was also afraid of conflict and all worked up, that the meeting ended abruptly when Ariel stormed out.
What did I do to intervene in the conflict? I don’t remember that I did much. Maybe it was that I couldn’t really do much to intervene; this was an ongoing conflict between mother and daughter, twenty or more years in the making, and they brought this thickness, this blackness, with them into the room. I remember feeling completely at a loss to do anything positive in the situation.
Once Ariel was out of the room, the social worker confronted the family. “You’ve got to make a choice here. You’ve got to make this an official case. That’s the only way she’s going to step up and do the things she needs to do. My hands are tied otherwise.” The family was adamant: they would not report her further, would not “put a black mark on her record.” She wanted a future working with children, they said. If they would report her in this situation, she would have a permanent record of child endangerment, and would never get to fulfill her dreams of working with children. They couldn’t be the ones to take her future away from her.
I kept trying to reschedule the family team meeting, to finish the meeting; nothing ever came of it.
Time passed, and the social worker left and a new one took her place. The new worker learned what had happened, or not happened, with the family, and made some tough decisions. She placed the children with one of Ariel’s sisters, and would have insisted on a termination of Ariel’s parental rights immediately because Ariel hadn’t really done anything much to get her life straightened out, but gave Ariel a break because she was new on the case. Ariel was appointed an attorney; her kids were appointed an attorney; a care coordinator began working with her family. The new social worker asked me to set up another family team meeting.
We gathered several months ago in my conference room. Ariel came with her dad; two sisters attended, plus one on the phone, along with Ariel’s mom, the new social worker, the children’s attorney, and the care coordinator. Again we introduced ourselves and discussed the guidelines for discussion.
This time I paid particular attention to the ideas of “intention” and “boundaries.” I listed the ones Ariel and I had decided on, a year and a half prior to this meeting, and asked the group if they knew of any other ones they’d like to have as guidelines for the discussion. “These are our intentions,” I said – “including to be respectful, and to be open and honest. Is there anything else you’d like to see here?” No one said anything. Ariel shook her head.
I thought I’d have to bring it up, because it was the elephant in the room, and everyone was aware that this meeting could devolve into another screaming match like the one we had before: “We had a meeting a year and a half ago, and it was a difficult meeting for everyone involved. What kind of boundaries would you like to have in place? Can you think of anything?” No one could think of anything. Dad spoke up: “I wasn’t here at that last meeting. I don’t know why I wasn’t here. And I don’t know what went on. But I don’t think we need any boundaries.”
I said “A boundary could be anything – like ‘treat each other with respect,’ ‘no yelling,’ ‘no cuss words,’ ‘no leaving the room until we’re done,’ anything like that.” Nobody spoke up.
Then I said “What I will say is that I’d like for everyone to be aware of how you’re feeling inside, during the meeting. Literally – pay attention to how you feel in your stomach. Monitor that for yourselves. Are you feeling calm? Peaceful? Are you tensing up? Starting to feel anxious? Feeling ‘butterflies’? Feeling like ‘oh, here we go again!’? Really pay attention to how you feel inside, and I will pay attention too. If you start feeling something like that, speak up and let me know. Then we can take a break, if you want, or we can look at the guidelines for discussion again and see if we need to look at one of them again or add one, or we can stop the meeting and reschedule it for another time, whatever you’d like to do. And I may check in now and then and see if this is working for you. Does that sound okay with everyone?” It did.
The meeting went on without a hitch. Ariel’s mom still poked at her a few times, and Ariel poked back at her mom a little, but it was much less intense than before. Ariel’s dad spoke up a few time to voice his opinion about how he thought Ariel got involved with the services; Ariel disagreed with the way he saw things, so I mediated that discussion and he settled down. I asked the group a time or two if this was working for them; it was.
Ariel was reluctant to list her strengths – the positive things she’d done since the last meeting – so others did that for her. She’d been in recovery for a while and had been sober for seven months; she was going to recovery meetings several times a week; she’d held the same job for a year; she’d lived in the same house for a year; her housekeeping was vastly improved over what it had been a year ago. Ariel said she didn’t feel comfortable bragging about herself, and this felt like bragging. The new worker said these were all positive things that she could show the judge to prove to the judge Ariel was making progress and needed to have her kids back home with her. “The judge will see this?” “Oh, definitely the judge will see this!”
We listed needs and concerns, created a short action plan, came up with a crisis plan and a next meeting date, and finished. Everyone walked out of the room feeling like we’d accomplished something huge.

Leave a Reply