Getting To No

I learned early that to stay safe, to survive in my environment, I had to silence my voice. I learned that I had to agree with everything the big people in my environment said and did. They were right. They were bigger, older, faster, stronger, and if I wanted food, if I wanted to be free from pain, if I wanted to be free from angry door slamming and tension and uncertainty and unpredictable encounters with the razor strop that hung menacingly from the bathroom radiator, I just needed to say yes, yes, yes. Yes, you are right. Yes, this way you require of me is correct. Yes.

I learned to be more than just a yes; I learned to be enthusiastically yes. YES, whatever you say. YES, to this, YES, most vehemently yes to that. If they were YES, I was you-are-absolutely-a-thousand-percent-right YES. I was the first one to stand in line shouting to the masses how YES I was and how right the YES was that I was advocating and how absolutely perfect this YES position was, because the people in my environment who were telling me this is the way it was, were right. They were the only ones who were right. I agreed with them because that was the only way to think about things. It was a no-brainer. It was absolute. I was YESsier than any other YES anyone could have ever imagined. Yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes.

Everything I did or said or thought, I did or said or thought in order to make points with them. To make them pleased with me. For their approval. So that I could survive.

To the best of my ability I out-thought them; I pre-thought them. What would be the safest thing for me to say and do in this situation? In that one? Before the potential abuse might happen, I tried to figure out the safest thing to say and do, to improve my chances of survival. Get good grades? Oh, okay — Iʻll get the best grades anyone ever got; Iʻll show YOU. Wear a knee-length dress in the days of miniskirts, because thatʻs what got me my YES? Sure! Iʻll wear whatever you want. Just approve of me. Iʻll go to school and tell everybody that short skirts were terrible. No makeup, because we donʻt do makeup in this household? Sure. Whatever you say. Makeup is for someone else, not me. Makeup is for girls who get themselves into trouble. I donʻt get in trouble.

I wasnʻt even aware it was happening, the giving-away of my voice. I remembered a few times when it was beaten out of me, “for my own good,” and the words spoken at the time were “this will hurt me more than it will hurt you,” but I didnʻt realize that my voice was slowly but surely going away. I traded what I knew to be true within me, for someone elseʻs voice, so that I could survive. So that I would be safe.

A boyfriend appeared. I stayed safe with him and kept my voice quietly tucked inside. I went to college and graduated in record time with the highest grades possible, so that everyone would be proud of me. My pottery teacher in college told me I needed to stay another year, get a third major, a major in art. How could I? I was already planning my wedding for the upcoming June. I couldnʻt back out now.

I married the boyfriend. He assumed the role of dictating what would and would not be acceptable for me to say and do and think — and I agreed with him. I said YES, most absolutely positively YES. Children came; I worked in a career I absolutely loved, a career where I could just sit and listen and take dictation and have no voice. My voice did not matter. On Saturday mornings I took pottery classes at the local cultural center. In pottery class we could have a voice with each other, because with these women, it didnʻt matter. We could laugh; we could say yes; we could also say no.

There came a day when I saw something that made me say NO. It was at work, during one of my assignments; I saw a husband sitting and verbally abusing his wife in front of his attorney and his wifeʻs attorney, and the wife sat there and just took it. Absorbed it. I could see that sheʻd been absorbing this for decades, and soon now she was going to be done taking it.

I most definitely wasnʻt going to allow that abuse to go on right in front of me. I said NO inside myself and asked for a break, requesting to talk to the attorneys privately. I learned that day that my voice did not matter. I was a mere court reporter and mattered to them about as much as a chair or the table mattered to them. I learned that if I spoke my truth and said NO, there will be no abuse, not in my presence, I wasnʻt going to be employed any longer. That day I decided I had to do something different. This wasnʻt working for me.

I remembered that right after college I wanted a masterʻs degree, but for the life of me couldnʻt figure out what area of interest that might be, so I just put that dream aside during the years of children, husband, courtrooms, and dictation. The dream came back, now that the children were leaving for college and coming home on holidays, talking about classes and professors and learning and books. I kept my ears open and looked for where the path might open up.

It was an ad on the local public radio station that caught my attention. I attended an orientation class and considered my options. Not even knowing what I was choosing, I strongly considered a masterʻs in conflict resolution. But was that logical? Iʻd never heard of a masterʻs in conflict resolution. What even was it? What do you do with it? What kind of jobs do you get with a masterʻs in conflict resolution? Is it practical? Could I make money with it?

I made it my mission for the next few months to get some answers. Someone out there had to know what it looked like, having a masterʻs in conflict resolution.

The next thing I knew I was in Minnesota, where the Mennonites had invited me to talk about my childrenʻs book at their regional conference. One of the presenters intrigued me, in the opening remarks at the conference. He was Black and referred to himself as the “token Black Mennonite” in his self-effacing good humor. He was also the keynote speaker at the first eveningʻs session. All told, over the two or three daysʻ time at the conference, we probably spent eight hours talking, an hour or two in the library here, an hour or two in the dining hall there. The gift he gave me changed my entire life.

I had to ask. I wanted to know if I could get a job in the field of conflict resolution. What did he know about that? What could he tell me about it?

He never answered my question, not in eight hours of conversation.

And, he gave me back my voice.

Of course my voice had never left me; Iʻd buried it somewhere deep inside, under all the YES YES A THOUSAND TIMES YES, under all the people-pleasing, manipulation, pre-thinking-out-thinking I had done for my whole life, so that I could survive and not be hurt.

He sat with me in those little rooms and asked me questions. Open-ended questions. Questions with no right answers. Questions that made me dig deep inside and give my answer, for ME.

I couldnʻt give him an answer that would please him, because he didnʻt really care what the answer was. I couldnʻt out-think him, because there was nothing to out-think. I was entirely safe. In those rooms there was nothing to fear. It didnʻt even matter if we were overheard. I couldnʻt give him an answer that would make him happy, or not give him an answer that would make him angry, because whatever I said, if it was true, if it was true for me, if it was my answer for me, then it was what I needed to say.

I probably cried most of the time we sat together.

No one in my life, ever, and by now I was 41, no one ever had just sat with me and asked me what was true for me now. What did I collect? What did I think about this topic, about that?

And the thing was: he sat still and listened. He didnʻt have to rush off to somewhere, to some other appointment, to another keynote address for the conference. He had time to spend with me as I melted down in front of him. We talked in several large chunks of time until I was talked out.

I really donʻt remember what we talked about, and that wasnʻt important. He listened. He made the space for me. I talked. I had never talked before, really. No one had ever made it safe for me to discover what was inside me, what “me being me” was all about. Who was I really? I really didnʻt know. I thought it was all the YES that I had been saying to everyone my whole life so that I would be safe. That wasnʻt the real me at all.

He told me, after I told him that I collected dishes, that I had a weird obsession with collecting sets of dishes — something that neither he nor I could figure out a symbolism for!! — that someone had asked him this question a long time before, in his life, when he was having a hard time himself. He was a man who had walked in protest alongside Dr. Martin Luther King. He was a classmate with Jesse Jackson. He recommended the movie “Mississippi Burning” to me, saying it was about as accurate a portrayal as anything I could watch, telling the story of him, his lifetime, the lives of people he knew.

His answer to the question “what do you collect?” was crucifixes. He had a vast collection of pictures of Jesus on the cross. His room was full of statues of Jesus, crucified. He wore crucifixes. What he identified with most was crucifixes.

The person who sat with him said to him, “John, take Jesus off the cross.”

In other words, stop seeing yourself as a victim.

We traded stories. He talked about Ebonics; I talked about Native American history. His children were part Native too.

Eventually we both had to go. I drove home, changed. I enrolled in the masterʻs program in conflict resolution, still having absolutely no idea what on earth Iʻd do with a masterʻs degree in conflict resolution; whether this would be a decision I would regret, whether I could pay off the student loan, whether I would ever get a job.

It was a confusing, sensual experience, being truly listened to for the first time in my life. It took a while for me to understand that this was not about attraction. This is how it feels, being honored. This is how it feels, being given air time. This is how it feels, for the first time ever, connecting with the Wisdom that is within. This is how it feels for that inner Wisdom to be released. This is how it feels, being listened to, respectfully, with no agenda in mind, nobody to please, nothing expected in return.

My life until then had been so transactional: say this, do this, I give you food. Behave this way, I give you approval and not a beating. Be as you were at age 17 when you were submissive and cute, or else Iʻll hit you. Yes, yes, yes, Iʻll be good. Yes, yes, yes, Iʻll behave. Yes, yes, yes, Iʻll say what you want me to say. Iʻll even believe that I believe it. Iʻll prove it to the whole world that I believe in you so much, Iʻll out-yes you and everyone else, proving it; just you watch.

I finished the course in conflict resolution, published my thesis, freed myself and my voice, and followed my dream of doing what I could to help Native women find their voice too. I facilitated meetings where Native families in danger of losing their children to the child welfare system could come into the meeting knowing they were respected, knowing they would have the time to express themselves fully and at their own pace, knowing their words were honored and valued, no matter what they said, and knowing that I would listen and take them seriously. I gave Native women a space — with plenty of tissue boxes handy — so that they could discover their truth within and speak it out loud in safety.

And in doing so, I learned the art of finally, finally, honoring my voice, getting to know who I truly am, and saying, clearly and confidently when I have to, and with the greatest love possible, NO.




Leave a Reply