A United Front, Not a Wall

A United Front, Not a Wall

I was the baby of the family, born eleven years after my five older siblings, who had arrived pretty much two years apart. Five stairstep kids, and then, years later, me.

One of the benefits of being the baby was watching my older brothers and sisters bring their own children home—children who were only a little younger than I was.

I got to watch my siblings make their parenting mistakes!

By the time I started having my own family, I had a pretty good idea what had worked and what hadn’t worked in raising me, and what I’d observed in the raising of my nieces and nephews.

Still, I asked my parents for advice.

After all, they’d raised six children on a farm, and all six had gone to the colleges of their choice and graduated with the degrees of their choice. They must have learned something along the way.

My parents didn’t have much advice to offer.

But one thing stuck with me:

Always present a united front to your children.

Meaning, never let your children see you fight.

Which is not to say that parents shouldn’t have disagreements. Of course they will! They’re two different people, with different histories, different perspectives, different ideas about how things ought to be done.

But my parents believed that those disagreements should be worked out privately, away from the children.

Looking back on my own childhood, I could see that they’d followed this rule pretty consistently.

What one parent said, the other backed up.

There wasn’t much point in trying to manipulate one parent into overruling the other. If Mom said no, going to Dad wasn’t likely to produce a yes.

Believe me, I knew.

And I did my best to follow their example when I raised my own children.

But over the years, through parenting, mediation, and working with families in conflict, I’ve come to understand something more about that advice.

A united front can be a good thing. But it shouldn’t become a wall.

Children need stability. They need to know that the adults responsible for their care can work together, make decisions, and provide a reasonably predictable, safe environment.

What they don’t need is to be caught in the middle of their parents’ arguments.

They don’t need to become messengers, referees, negotiators, or little diplomats trying desperately to keep the peace.

They don’t need to decide which parent is right.

And they certainly don’t need to feel responsible for making the adults in their lives happy.

That’s not their job.

But there’s something else children can learn from their parents, and it may be just as important as seeing them agree.

They can learn how to disagree.

They can see Mom and Dad have different opinions and still respect one another.

They can hear one parent say, “I hadn’t thought about it that way.”

They can watch someone change their mind.

They can see a parent acknowledge a mistake, apologize, and make things right.

They can discover that disagreement doesn’t necessarily mean danger, rejection, or the end of a relationship.

And perhaps most importantly, they can learn that it’s safe to have a voice of their own.

Because two parents agreeing with each other doesn’t automatically mean they’re right.

Sometimes the child has something important to say, too.

Sometimes the adults need to listen.

The goal isn’t to create a household where everyone always agrees.

It’s to create a family where people can disagree without threatening one another’s safety, dignity, or belonging.

That doesn’t mean every parental disagreement should take place in front of the children.

Some conversations really do belong behind closed doors, especially when emotions are running high or the issues concern the adult relationship.

And children should never have to witness intimidation, threats, cruelty, or frightening confrontations and be told that this is simply how adults work things out.

But respectful disagreement? Listening? Apologizing? Finding a way forward together?

Those are skills children can carry with them for the rest of their lives.

And where better to learn them than at home?

Parents aren’t always going to agree. They’re not always going to make the right decisions, either.

They’re human.

There’s a time and a place to work on the relationship, to listen openly to one another, to express what each person knows to be true, to disagree, to reconsider, to grow as individuals and as partners.

This isn’t easy work.

Sometimes it helps to have a quiet room, away from the pressures of home, where both people can speak and be heard without interruption.

That’s one of the things mediation can offer.

Not someone to decide who’s right or wrong.

Not an expert to tell parents how to raise their children.

But an opportunity for two people to listen to themselves, listen to each other, and discover what will work for their family.

Because children don’t need parents who have all the answers.

They need adults who can work together, take responsibility for their own behavior, and make room for one another’s voices.

Including the voices of their children.

A united front, yes.

But never a wall.